
Over diversification in mutual funds
Quick answer:
Over diversification means holding so many mutual funds that they overlap and add cost and complexity without reducing risk. Most investors do well with about 3-5 funds across equity, debt and, if needed, gold, but the right number depends on your goals.
Over Diversification is traditionally promoted as one of the golden rules of investing. By diversifying your investments across a range of asset classes, industries, or geographies, you reduce the chances of disastrous loss. Nevertheless, like every other strategy, even diversification has its limits. When taken too far — more so in terms of mutual funds — it creates a condition of over-diversification. This effect can dilute your profits and make it harder to balance your portfolio.
In this article, we analyse why Over diversification can fail, how to recognise that you are over-diversified, and how to maximise your mutual fund returns.
The Logic Behind Diversification
Over Diversification aims to minimise unsystematic risk, which arises from exposure to a particular security or industry, by spreading investments across multiple instruments. Mutual funds offer this benefit automatically, as each fund invests in a portfolio of securities. This makes them particularly appealing to individual investors who may not have sufficient capital to build a diversified portfolio independently.
However, here’s where things get a little complicated: many investors assume that holding more mutual funds automatically leads to greater diversification. But that’s not necessarily true.
The Flaw of Over-Diversification
1. Diminishing Returns
Over-diversification spreads your investment so much that your winning funds or sectors contribute less to your total returns. Your winners are essentially diluted by the sheer quantity of other stocks.
2. Overlapping Holdings
Mutual funds in the same fund category or even a different investment category tend to have many of the same holdings. For instance, if you have four large-cap stock funds, there is a strong likelihood that they all hold slices of some of the same blue-chip stocks. So, you may think that you have diversified your investments, but in reality, you can end up with more exposure to the very same assets.
3. Increased Costs
Mutual funds come with expenses such as expense ratios, management fees, and exit loads. Holding too many funds can increase your overall investment costs. Moreover, frequent transactions while managing or rebalancing a large portfolio may lead to additional expenses, including brokerage charges and taxes. Over time, these costs can eat into your investment returns.
4. Complicated Portfolio Management
Maintaining a portfolio of 8 to 12 mutual funds—a common practice among individual investors— requires considerable time and effort. Tracking fund performance, reviewing portfolio holdings, understanding tax implications, and rebalancing investments periodically can become overwhelming. For most investors, managing such a complex portfolio may lead to negligence, delayed decisions, and ultimately, poor investment choices.
5. Portfolio Redundancy
Too often, investors choose mutual funds based on their recent performance rather than their actual financial goals or portfolio requirements. This can result in a cluster of funds with similar investment objectives and overlapping holdings, offering little additional diversification. For instance, investing in five different mid-cap funds simply because all of them performed well last year may not add much value to your portfolio in the long run.
How Many Mutual Funds Are Enough?
The ideal number of mutual funds would depend on your investment goals, tenure, and risk-taking capacity:
- Equity Mutual Funds: 2-3 diversified schemes spanning alternate market capitalisations and sectors are sufficient for most investors. For example, one large-cap, one mid-cap or flexi-cap, and one sectoral or thematic scheme (optional) can provide considerable diversification.
- Debt Mutual Funds: 1 or 2 funds, e.g., a short-duration debt fund and a liquid fund, can manage risk and serve liquidity needs for the short term.
- Hybrid Funds: If you want a one-stop solution, a balanced or aggressive hybrid fund could minimise the need to keep separate equity and debt funds.
Tips to Avoid Over-Diversification
1. Know Your Investment Objectives
You must be well-versed in your financial goals before you begin investing; otherwise, you will invest without any legitimate aim.
2. Review Existing Holdings Before Investing In New Ones
Before investing in a new fund, see how much its holdings overlap with your existing funds. Most investment platforms and tools offer analytics that can assist you in reviewing overlap and sectoral exposure.
3. Don’t Follow the Herd
Don’t be a herd follower by investing in the “best-performing fund of the year.” Past performance cannot define future returns. Be consistent and don’t go for random diversification.
4. Consolidate When Convenient
If you have a bunch of funds with the same goal and comparable holdings, consider consolidating them. This simplifies monitoring and rebalancing and can save you money.
5. Rebalance Occasionally
An annual update of your portfolio should be adequate for most investors. In doing so, check performance, re-jig asset allocation, and shut down outperformers or duplicative funds.
Is Your Portfolio Over-Diversified?
Ask yourself:
- Do I own more than 6-7 mutual funds?
- Are there several funds of the same group (i.e., three big-cap funds)?
- Do I understand what each fund in my portfolio is doing?
- Do I struggle to track performance or rebalance?
If you said “yes” to most of them, chances are you’re over-diversified.
Final Thoughts
Diversification is a vital pillar of good investing. However, over-diversification can reduce your profits and also make your investment experience unnecessarily complicated. Opt for a smaller, target-oriented, and research-based portfolio instead. Sound investing is about owning the right things in the right mix.
Please share your thoughts on this post by leaving a reply in the comments section. Contact us via Phone, WhatsApp, or Email to learn more about mutual funds, or visit our website https://prodigypro.co.in/.
Alternatively, you can download the Prodigy Pro app to start investing today!
Disclaimer – This article is for educational purposes only and does not intend to substitute expert guidance. Mutual fund investments are subject to market risks. Please read the scheme-related document carefully before investing.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. How many mutual funds should I ideally own in my portfolio?
Most investors fare well with 3 to 5 mutual funds that are strategically diversified by asset class, depending on your goals. The idea is to achieve maximum diversification without duplication.
2. How can I determine if my mutual funds overlap holdings?
Or, just employ portfolio analysis software provided by investing websites. Or, list the top 10 holdings of each fund from their fact sheets and determine if the same stocks show up in several funds.
3. Do I lose money if I over-diversify?
Not necessarily. But it tends to yield average or mediocre returns, particularly if better-performing funds are watered down by weak or redundant performers.
4. Do I have more than one fund belonging to the same category?
Having a single or double fund within each category (large-cap, mid-cap, debt, etc.) is generally sufficient. Having multiple ones creates overlap and duplication.
5. Can a financial advisor help me consolidate my portfolio?
Yes. A trained financial advisor can look over your existing portfolio, identify the overlapping areas, and provide consolidation plans that suit your own financial goals.